Using Mac Frameworks in Qt App

[yogeshgokul]

I am using Mac's framework named "System/Library/Frameworks/DiscRecording.framework" in my qt App. For this I added 2 lines in .pro file.

QMAKE_LFLAGS += -L/System/Library/Frameworks/DiscRecording
LIBS += -framework DiscRecording

In one of my header file I included this framework e.g
#include "DiscRecording/DiscRecording.h" // Including master header file for the framework

but when I try to create object of one of the class on that framework "e.g DRDevice obj", I am getting this error:
"error: 'DRDevice' does not name a type"

How to remove this error

[jpn]

Is "DRDevice" declared in DiscRecording.h? Where is DiscRecording.h? Perhaps you should add

INCLUDEPATH += /path/to/DiscRecording/includes

to your .pro file?

[yogeshgokul]

DiskRecording.h is master header file for this framework. So we only need to include this file to have all the functionality of that framework(with all header files included).

And I tried this INCLUDEPATH method. Didnt work.

[jpn]

Could you answer my question? Exactly where is DiscRecording.h?

Let's imagine DiscRecording.h is in "/path/to/DiscRecording/DiscRecording.h". Now, if you include "DiscRecording/DiscRecording.h", you should add

INCLUDEPATH += /path/to

But if you include "DiscRecording.h", you should add

INCLUDEPATH += /path/to/DiscRecording

[yogeshgokul]

Hi jpn,

I am sorry if I could not make myself clear. The answer to your question is:
DiscRecording.h is in /System/Library/Frameworks/DiscRecording.framework/headers folder.

You can check this framework in /System/Library/Frameworks folder on mac machine.

BTW, I don't get any file include error. When I say
#include "DiscRecording/DiscRecording.h"
it can very well include the file. Only problem that I understand is that it is not able to properly include its inner frameworks like DiscRecordingEngine and DiscRecordingContent.

I have studied qt assistant about how to include frameworks in qt projects on mac and doing the same way. I will be very great full if somebody can help me right here!! :-)

Regards,
Yogesh

[jpn]

I am sorry if I could not make myself clear. The answer to your question is:
DiscRecording.h is in /System/Library/Frameworks/DiscRecording.framework/headers folder.

Are you sure it's "headers"? Or is it "Headers"? Your file system is case sensitive, right?

You can check this framework in /System/Library/Frameworks folder on mac machine.

Unfortunately I don't have a Mac.

BTW, I don't get any file include error. When I say
#include "DiscRecording/DiscRecording.h"
it can very well include the file. Only problem that I understand is that it is not able to properly include its inner frameworks like DiscRecordingEngine and DiscRecordingContent.

Well, presumably something goes wrong if the type is declared in that header but it's still unknown after trying to include the header file.

Does this work?

LIB_NAME = DiscRecording
FRAMEWORK_PATH = /System/Library/Frameworks
 
FRAMEWORK_INCLUDE = $${FRAMEWORK_PATH}/$${LIB_NAME}.framework/headers # Headers or headers??
exists($$FRAMEWORK_INCLUDE) {
   INCLUDEPATH -= $$FRAMEWORK_INCLUDE
   INCLUDEPATH = $$FRAMEWORK_INCLUDE $$INCLUDEPATH
}
LIBS += -framework $${LIB_NAME}

LIB_NAME = DiscRecording
FRAMEWORK_PATH = /System/Library/Frameworks

FRAMEWORK_INCLUDE = $${FRAMEWORK_PATH}/$${LIB_NAME}.framework/headers # Headers or headers??
exists($$FRAMEWORK_INCLUDE) {
   INCLUDEPATH -= $$FRAMEWORK_INCLUDE
   INCLUDEPATH = $$FRAMEWORK_INCLUDE $$INCLUDEPATH
}
LIBS += -framework $${LIB_NAME}

To copy to clipboard, switch view to plain text mode 

Presumably you should try with include "DiscRecording.h" since you say the file is in "/System/Library/Frameworks/DiscRecording.framework/headers/DiscRecording.h". However, it would be include "DiscRecording/DiscRecording.h" if it was in "/System/Library/Frameworks/DiscRecording.framework/headers/DiscRecording/DiscRecording.h".

[yogeshgokul]

Are you sure it's "headers"? Or is it "Headers"? Your file system is case sensitive, right?

It is "Headers", but it does not make any difference as we can not write it in include path. All header files are automatically included by DiscRecording.h file and the framework have multiple sub frameworks having multiple Headers folders.


Unfortunately I don't have a Mac.


Well, presumably something goes wrong if the type is declared in that header but it's still unknown after trying to include the header file.

Does this work?

LIB_NAME = DiscRecording
FRAMEWORK_PATH = /System/Library/Frameworks
 
FRAMEWORK_INCLUDE = $${FRAMEWORK_PATH}/$${LIB_NAME}.framework/headers # Headers or headers??
exists($$FRAMEWORK_INCLUDE) {
   INCLUDEPATH -= $$FRAMEWORK_INCLUDE
   INCLUDEPATH = $$FRAMEWORK_INCLUDE $$INCLUDEPATH
}
LIBS += -framework $${LIB_NAME}

LIB_NAME = DiscRecording
FRAMEWORK_PATH = /System/Library/Frameworks

FRAMEWORK_INCLUDE = $${FRAMEWORK_PATH}/$${LIB_NAME}.framework/headers # Headers or headers??
exists($$FRAMEWORK_INCLUDE) {
   INCLUDEPATH -= $$FRAMEWORK_INCLUDE
   INCLUDEPATH = $$FRAMEWORK_INCLUDE $$INCLUDEPATH
}
LIBS += -framework $${LIB_NAME}

To copy to clipboard, switch view to plain text mode 

Above solution can not work for the reason that framework has multiple sub frameworks with multiple Headers folders.

Presumably you should try with include "DiscRecording.h" since you say the file is in "/System/Library/Frameworks/DiscRecording.framework/headers/DiscRecording.h". However, it would be include "DiscRecording/DiscRecording.h" if it was in "/System/Library/Frameworks/DiscRecording.framework/headers/DiscRecording/DiscRecording.h".

I tried this but then it give the error "No such file" for DiscRecording.h

[jpn]

Could you attach the output of

ls -laR /System/Library/Frameworks/DiscRecording.framework

AND the full compiler command including all switches before the "no such file" message.

[yogeshgokul]

Please find the attached 2 files containing build output and output of command.

[jpn]

So, it seems to be "Headers", not "headers" as you said..... Spot my comment "# Headers or headers??" and fix it. Also, could you answer to my very first question? Are you sure "DRDevice" is even declared in DiscRecording.h or in its further includes?

[yogeshgokul]

Yes DRDevice is included in header files. And as I mentioned that this is umbrella framework, so we only need to include single master header file in our project.
I am still struggling in same problem described in 1st post of this thread

[jpn]

Would you mind attaching DiscRecording.h?

[TimButterfield]

If I understand what you are trying to do, it seems like you are trying to use the DiscRecording classes directly from C++. IIRC, DiscRecording is part of the Cocoa framework and is written in Objective-C, not C++. I have not tried this with Qt, but you may need to do the equivalent of writing C callable wrapper functions for the objective-C objects. The Cocoa-Carbon integration guide may help you with this.

[THRESHE]

And why don't you want to create Xcode project and just simply add this framework to your Xcode project ? I'm using this framework right now with Xcode

[TimButterfield]

I'm using this framework right now with Xcode

Just curious...
Are you able to use it directly with Qt or did you need to create a wrapper like I suspected?

Thanks.

[THRESHE]

Just curious...
Are you able to use it directly with Qt or did you need to create a wrapper like I suspected?
Thanks.

No I've just used C functions from DiscRecording framework. Carbon API is implemented not just in Objective-C but also has implementation in C language If you are interested I can provide you with useful links on ADC

[TimButterfield]

No I've just used C functions from DiscRecording framework. Carbon API is implemented not just in Objective-C but also has implementation in C language If you are interested I can provide you with useful links on ADC

I'm an ADC Select member; it's probably on my Feb. DVD. I think I can find it. Thanks.

On second thought... since it is on this thread, perhaps the links could be of use for yogeshgokul's issue.